.comment-link {margin-left:.6em;}

David @ Tokyo

Perspective from Japan on whaling and whale meat, a spot of gourmet news, and monthly updates of whale meat stockpile statistics



IWC 2006: Live blogging - Day 1

[22:30 JST] Today I'll be doing my first attempt at live blogging. The IWC plenary session is due to get underway 30 minutes from now. This first morning will basically set the tone for the rest of the meeting. News reports out today suggest that neither the pro-sustainable use side or the anti-whaling side is confident they have a voting majority. We'll know shortly which nations have actually showed up.

The first item on the agenda is just some formalities, with perhaps some statements by new members.
The second item is the adoption of the agenda, which I imagine should be straightforward.
The third item is the issue of protest activities in the Antarctic. Japan is seeking either a resolution or a recommendation from the IWC here, but given the highly controversial nature of the protests, even some anti-whaling nations may side with Japan on the issue.
The fourth item on the agenda, later in the day, is regarding secret ballots. I'm picking that this vote will be the one that tells us how the rest of the meeting will play out. If secret ballots are adopted, the meeting will likely go very much in favour of the sustainable use nations.

Stay tuned for more! I'll continue to update this article throughout the evening (JST)

[22:45 JST] There have been suggestions today that Guatemala will not participate at the IWC meeting, this year, although they have recently joined. We'll know shortly exactly what the situation is. We can expect to see no shows from both camps.

[22:55 JST] Switzerland's name has been bandied about as a nation that is in the middle ground at the IWC. Last year however, they voted against Japan on all but one issue (and on that one issued they abstained). Nonetheless, the Swiss maintain that they are happy to talk to both sides.

[23:05 JST] Just waiting for the live feed to come up. In the meantime, Joji Morishita spoke with Australian media today.

[23:25 JST] The proceedings are now underway. The St. Kitts Prime Minister is making his welcoming address. He sounds rather nervous, but is stressing the need to respect different cultures and viewpoints.

[23:26 JST] A band is now treating the audience to some Caribbean music. It's fabulous :-)

[23:28 JST] As the band wraps up, I'll add a link to another interview with Joji Morishita.

[23:35 JST] The St Kitts commissioner, Cedric Liburd, is making an eloquent speech urging the IWC to ensure that the meeting offers benefits through development for the nations of the Caribbean, which are gradually adjusting to a globalized world. He is stressing that in the Caribbean, they have more sea than land, and that this is where people are looking to for potential sustainable development opportunities through effective management of oceanic resources.

[23:38 JST] Cedric Liburd is now explicitly rejecting the allegations of bribery to the meeting. He is urging the IWC to get past the propaganda, and work together through dialogue.

[23:40 JST] That's it for now folks - they are breaking for coffee!! Come back in 35 minutes time. Go watch the Soccer World Cup or something :-)

[23:58 JST] The Opening statement of Japan's Commissioner to the IWC (word version) has been released to the media.

[00:19 JST] OK, just waiting for the end of the break... How much coffee do they need?

[00:28 JST] Underway again. The US was decided upon as the Vice Chair (I believe). Next come the opening statements from new members, if they wish.

[00:30 JST] The Mali delegate is making his opening statement, in French. Everyone has pulled out their headsets. This would be interesting to understand, as Mali is the 2nd of the two landlocked nations believed to be likely to vote with the pro-sustainable use nations. Can any of my readers summarize this? This must be Dr. H. Coulibaly. Kindly summarized by isanatori: "Roughly summarised, the representative from Mali recalled what was the orginal objectives of the ICRW - conservation of whales and sustainable use of this ressources - and appealed to all the member states to respect it."

[00:38 JST] Now the Israel delegate is speaking. She is saying "protect" quite a lot.

[00:41 JST] Israel is done. Basically they just want to participate at the IWC for protection of whales. Next is Cambodia.

[00:43 JST] The alternate commissioner for Cambodia noted that Cambodia is dependant on the use of natural resources. He is commenting on the dysfunctional nature of the IWC. He is stating his belief that decisions be based on scientific research. He states that Cambodia is confident that the IWC can move forwards.

[00:45 JST] The Marshall Islands is now speaking. The delegate is stating that his country has carefully considered it's joining of the IWC, noting the cost as one issue preventing this. But given that they are an island nation, they feel that they can not relax under their coconut trees while decisions that may effect them may be being made in international forums. The Marshall Islands are interested in fisheries resources, and are interested in conservation of all marine resources, for the sustainable development of their country and people.

[00:49 JST] Next on the agenda - voting credentials. Costa Rico, Gambia, Peru, Togo, and maybe one other nation have had their voting rights suspended - I think I missed one other nation there - who was it? Maybe it was Kenya, as they never turn up to vote either. We'll try to get this info up later.

[00:56 JST] Just going through some boring administrative stuff right now.

[01:00 JST] Adoption of the Agenda. Ian Campbell is complaining about the new item of "normalization" of the IWC, added at the request of Japan. Campbell is asking that the agenda item be renamed "modernization" of the IWC, noting that much has changed since 1946. Henrik Fischer is disagreeing, but passing the floor to Japan. Japan has responded that it will explain the meaning of "normalization" under that part of the agenda. Japan notes that it can't agree to change the wording to "modernization", if the intended meaning is "total prohibition" [of whaling]. Brazil is speaking now as well. Henrik Fischer is noting that no nations have expressed concerns about the naming of this item prior to today. He is asking everyone to just accept it as is so that the meeting can proceed.

[01:08 JST] New Zealand now speaking to Japan's point on the agenda item on small ceteceans. This is Sir Geoff Palmer. Gosh, he's balded quite a lot since I last saw him. Blah blah blah. He's going on for ages - Japan has called for a point of order. Henrik Fischer is clearly annoyed already. Fischer is of the opinion that as there is not consensus on the issue of small cetaceans, so hopes that the meeting can proceed, noting Japan's position, as has been done in previous years. Geoff Palmer has shut up now. Back to Japan.

[01:16 JST] Japan is calling for a vote on the deletion of the "actions arising" agenda item regarding small cetaceans, as the IWC is a democratic organization. The right to delete an agenda item is (apparently) a right of the ICRW signatories.

[01:19 JST] Henrik Fischer is going to make a ruling, noting that he is in a prisoner's dilemma. He is allowing Japan to put the question to a vote.

[01:23 JST] After some confusion, Japan is happy to vote on the proposal. However, they wish to explain the proposal before the vote is taken. As soon as he starts to give his explanation, the Australian delegation have interuppted him. The Japanese delegate (Joji Morishita) has a wry grin on his face. Australia is complaining that the vote should be taken immediately, without an explanation from Japan, based on the rules.

[01:26 JST] Henrik Fischer is putting his foot down now. Lots of time has been wasted on this. Brazil is complaining again, but now Japan is again with the floor to explain. Japan notes that they are happy to discuss matters of substance, but is not interested in arguing over procedural matters. Morishita is stating that Japan's position is basically the same as previous years, except this year they are only proposing the single item on "actions arising". Japan's position is that the global IWC organization is not the right place to discuss the management of regional small cetacean species. Management is neccessary, but other forums should be used to persue such issues. In the past, Japan has received resolutions telling them what to do in their 200m EEZ with regard to these species. He notes that only Japan was targetted with these resolutions. He notes that Japan's position is that as the IWC can't manage global species, it shouldn't try to manage small cetaceans. Morishita hopes to have an open vote on the issue now. He hopes (with a smile) that nations will not do "automatic voting", but actually think before doing so.

Henrik is now allowing some more speakers some brief time, but isn't going to let this drag on into the afternoon. Britain is talking a load of nonsense. Japan only asked for deletion of "actions arising", yet Britain is talking as if Japan has asked to delete small cetacean issues from the agenda entirely. He is now regurgitating the same issues that have been discussed in previous years.

[01:39 JST] Only 5 more speakers on this issue. Blah blah blah. Uh oh - Geoff Palmer has got the floor again. ... Phew... wasn't too long after all. Brazil and the Netherlands are messing with Henrik Fischer now. He notes that he addressed their point 45 minutes ago already. Now the Netherlands is trying to say that they wanted to speak to the ruling 45 minutes ago. He says that the meeting staff saw this. But the meeting staff member stated she didn't recall any such thing. Henrik has reasserted that his ruling was not challenged originally.

[01:55 JST] Almost an hour of time wasted now. Japan maintains that it would like to vote on the proposal.

[02:02 JST] Close, but 30-32 against Japan's proposal, 1 abstention! The anti-whalers have this initial vote. The anti-whaling bloc got a vote from Belize that they would note have been expecting - Belize did not vote last year. Oman also supported the usual 30 anti-whaling nations, while Denmark's abstention also meant a lost vote for the pro-conservation camp. Senegal and Guatemala were not present for the voting.

With this first vote down, they have broken for lunch.

[02:17 JST] Just looking back on how the votes stack up, the sustainable use camp lost two potential votes due to The Gambia and and Togo not having their fees paid (I believe this was the reason). Guatemala is not present, and Senegal did not vote (not sure whether they are actually present or not). That alone cuts the 37 votes down to 33. Here, Belize also voted against the motion, which would have been somewhat unexpected. Oman displays quite independant voting habits, and voted against the motion in this particular case. And additionally, Denmark's abstention left the pro-conservation countries with only 30 votes, while the anti-whaling nations' votes were boosted up to 32. Slight voting fluctuations are not unusual. Last year, the anti-whaling side had votes ranging in the range from 29 t o31. The upcoming secret ballot vote passing is looking unlikely at this stage however.

This post is getting rather long now, so I'll resume again in a new post after the lunch break.


Thank you for your nice real-time report.

Glad to enjoy how the IWC will be
going with you and all pro-whaling

You can join in too, if you have RealPlayer :-)
YES! I am standing by REAL Player.
I am ready to wait for it to start!

Hi David,
Hajimemashite, Y/H-san,

I've catched the broadcast while Cedric Liburd was doing his speech.That's quite interesting, specially his negation of bribery accusation.

I'm impatient how will be the atmosphere when the debates and votes begin.

Nice idea of you to make real-time report.
isanatori - the report writing should help keep me awake through the night! These coffee breaks may be welcome in St. Kitts, but not so good for me trying to stay awake in front of the computer :-)
Hopefully, it's saturday, tomorrow.
Are you working on saturdays?

It's only 16:49 for me, so I certainly won't have to stay awake until late.

"Bon courage" to you!
Thankfully I can sleep as long as I like tomorrow :-)
It's almost midnight now, but some of the most interesting stuff today won't happen for a few hours yet. Agenda item 5, "Whales Stocks" should be very interesting.

>Hajimemashite, Y/H-san,

How do you do?
Hajimemashite Isanatori-san.

Happy to talk with you.
Let's enjoy the IWC together!

What annoy me is that, it will be difficult to wtch both the World Cup and the debates at the IWC...

I'll need to clone myself. :p

I wonder what time it is there, in St Kitts & Nevis...
I`m sleepy.I have to go to
office tommorow...

They are GMT - 4 hours in St Kitts.

Well Y/H-san, if you need to go to the office, you could always get up a bit early to watch video highlights at e-kujira! ganbatte!
isanatori said...
What annoy me is that, it will be difficult to wtch both the World Cup and the debates at the IWC...

I'll need to clone myself. :p

Ah... thats why I use two screens ;)
They did say the meeting would resume at 11:15, right?
>you could always get up a bit >early to watch video highlights >at e-kujira! ganbatte!

OH! Thank you.
Unfortunately the band is

Tomorrow, I will be back again.
Good night,David-san & Isanatori-san! See you tomorrow.

it´s just restarted
Good! Mali representative is doing is speech in french!
Roughly summarised, the representative from Mali recalled what was the orginal objectives of the ICRW - conservation of whales and sustainable use of this ressources - and appealed to all the member states to respect it.
Thanks! I copied that back up to the main blog entry :-)
I guess that Campbell's demand to change "normalization" into "modernization" is just a way to waste time for more usefull issues...
Yep... a total waste of time. Expect much much more of this!
And now New Zealand about small cetaceans...
They're very much good at this, I guess. Long years of training and experience.
Man! More wasting of time!
I used to assist to reunions at the Coucil of Europe. The adoption of agenda never took more than 10 minutes there, even when there wasn't consensus.

The anti-whaling countries should be ashamed of what they're doing. They're just like children.
30 for and 32 against...
So this year again, the pro-sustainable use camp won't have a majority...
isanatori - too early to say, I think - every vote going forward will be very tight. Here the anti-whaling side picked up a vote from Belize which would have been unexpected. Oman sided with the anti-whalers on this issue, but on others they may side with Japan. Denmark also abstained here. We'll need to watch each vote :-)
>So this year again, the pro->sustainable use camp won't have a >majority...

Gooo morning!

Sad to hear the news above!

Small countries might be
threatened before the IWC
starts.(especilally by GP)

Post a Comment

<< Home


June 2004   July 2004   August 2004   September 2004   October 2004   November 2004   December 2004   January 2005   March 2005   April 2005   May 2005   June 2005   July 2005   August 2005   September 2005   October 2005   November 2005   December 2005   January 2006   February 2006   March 2006   April 2006   May 2006   June 2006   July 2006   August 2006   September 2006   October 2006   November 2006   December 2006   January 2007   February 2007   March 2007   April 2007   May 2007   June 2007   July 2007   August 2007   September 2007   October 2007   November 2007   December 2007   January 2008   February 2008   April 2008   May 2008   June 2008   July 2008   August 2008   September 2008   October 2008   November 2008   December 2008   January 2009   February 2009   March 2009   April 2009   May 2009   June 2009   July 2009   August 2009   September 2009   October 2009   November 2009   January 2010   February 2010   April 2010   May 2010   June 2010   July 2010   August 2010   September 2010   February 2011   March 2011   May 2013   June 2013  

This page is powered by Blogger. Isn't yours?